Must try in Uzbekistan

Osh Palov.

Name: Osh Palov (Uzbek Lamb and Carrot Rice Pilaf)
Prep time: 40 min
Cook time: 1 h 30 min
Total time: 2 h 25 min
Yield: 6 servings
Cuisine: Uzbekistan
Ingredients: 700 g devzira or other short-grain rice; 1 tbsp salt, for the soaking water; 80 ml sunflower or cottonseed oil; 100 g lamb fat, diced small; 800 g lamb shoulder, in 4 cm chunks, some on the bone; 3 onions, halved and thinly sliced; 800 g yellow carrots, in 5 mm batons; 2 tsp whole cumin seed, crushed between the palms; 1 tsp coriander seed, lightly crushed; 1 tsp coarsely ground black pepper; 1 tbsp dried barberries or 1 tbsp raisins; 80 g dried chickpeas, soaked overnight; 1 whole dried red chilli; 2 tsp salt, or more to taste; 1 l hot water; 2 whole heads of garlic, papery outer skin rubbed off

Uzbek Lamb and Carrot Rice Pilaf

Osh / Palov · say it: OSH pah-LOV

Osh — palov to most Uzbeks, plov to the rest of the region — is a one-cauldron rice dish in which nothing is stirred until the moment it is served. Lamb and onion are fried hard in rendered fat until deeply browned, a thick raft of yellow carrots goes on top, water and cumin turn that into a dark, salty broth called zirvak, and only then does rice go in as a final flat layer to absorb the liquid and steam through. The result tastes of sweet caramelised carrot and lamb fat carried on cumin, with grains that stay separate and glossy rather than creamy. It is celebration food and weekday lunch at once, cooked in quantities that assume company, and it is the dish Uzbeks use to judge a cook.

Jump to the recipe

Read the story

Uzbek Lamb and Carrot Rice Pilaf

Gate: UzbekistanFergana Valley
Prep: 40 min
Cook: 1 hr 30 min
Total time: 2 hr 25 min incl. 15 min rest
Serves: 6
Status: Medium
Nutrition / serving · estimated: Calories 720 kcal; Protein 32 g; Carbs 78 g; Fat 32 g; Fiber 5 g; Sugar 8 g; Sodium 980 mg

Why this recipe works.

Builds a proper zirvak first, so the rice is seasoned by broth rather than by salt sprinkled on at the end.
Layered and never stirred — the honest Uzbek method, which is what keeps the grains separate.
Tells you what to do without devzira rice or fat-tailed sheep fat, instead of pretending you have them.
Feeds six generously from one pot, and the leftovers reheat better than almost any other rice dish.

Tips from our kitchen.

Rinse the rice until the water runs almost clear, then soak it in warm salted water for 30 minutes — this is the single biggest factor in separate grains.
Cut the carrots into batons by hand, roughly 5 mm thick. Grated or food-processed carrot collapses into orange mush and the dish loses its texture entirely.
Brown the onion further than feels comfortable — deep brown at the edges, not pale gold. That colour is where the dark tone of the finished rice comes from.
Once the rice goes in, do not stir. Move liquid around by poking holes down to the base with a chopstick if you need it to drain faster.
Salt the zirvak until it tastes distinctly too salty on its own. The unseasoned rice will absorb all of it and land correctly.
If the rice is still firm when the liquid is gone, sprinkle over 50 ml hot water, re-cover and steam another 10 minutes rather than adding a big splash.

Substitutions.

Devzira rice → Any short or medium-grain rice that holds its shape — Spanish bomba or calasparra, Italian arborio at a push, or a good basmati: Devzira drinks far more liquid than most rice. With basmati use about 15 percent less water and check earlier; with bomba the timings here are close to right.
Fat-tailed sheep fat (dumba) → 80 ml sunflower or cottonseed oil plus 100 g diced lamb fat trimmed from the shoulder: Rendering the trimmed fat first gets you part of the way. Cottonseed oil is what most Uzbek cooks actually use and its nutty smell is closer to the real thing than sunflower.
Lamb shoulder → Beef chuck or shin, cut the same size: Common in Tashkent and entirely acceptable. Beef needs about 20 extra minutes of simmering in the zirvak before the rice goes on.
Yellow carrots → Ordinary orange carrots: Yellow carrots are less sweet and hold their shape better, but orange ones are what most people have. Fry them a minute less so they do not go jammy.

Variations.

Fergana (dark) palov: Fry the carrots longer, until they are visibly browned, and use devzira rice. The finished dish is turned over on the platter and mixed so every grain takes on the colour of the zirvak.
Samarkand palov: Cooked the same way but never mixed: rice is spooned onto the platter first, then the carrots, then the meat sliced on top, so the layers stay visible and the rice stays pale.
Toy oshi (wedding palov): The celebration version, enriched with chickpeas, raisins and sometimes whole quince, cooked in a cauldron for hundreds and served in the morning.

Storage & reheating.

Palov keeps 3 days refrigerated and genuinely improves overnight as the fat and broth settle into the grains. Reheat covered, either in a pan over low heat with a tablespoon of water, or in a steamer basket for 10 minutes, which is what Uzbek homes do. Avoid the microwave on high — it dries the top layer and turns the carrots rubbery. It freezes acceptably for a month in flat portions, though the carrots soften noticeably on thawing.

Serve with

Achichuk — a raw salad of thinly sliced tomato and onion with no oil at all, whose entire job is to cut the fat of the rice. Torn obi non and pots of green tea, poured and refilled throughout the meal.

The story behind Osh Palov.

Palov belongs to the whole Persian-Turkic world — Iran, Afghanistan, Azerbaijan and Tajikistan all have their own claim on the pilaf family, and no honest account hands the invention to a single country. What Uzbekistan has is a specific, obsessively defended method: build a zirvak, layer rather than mix, never stir the rice, and finish with whole heads of garlic pushed into the surface. UNESCO listed the practice of cooking and sharing palov in both Uzbekistan and Tajikistan as intangible cultural heritage, which is a diplomatic way of admitting that both are right.

Inside Uzbekistan the argument continues by region. Fergana palov is the dark one — the carrots fry longer, the rice is devzira, a plump reddish local grain that drinks a lot of broth, and the finished dish is turned over and mixed on the platter. Bukharan and Samarkand palov stay pale and are served in layers, rice below, carrots and meat spooned on top, so the diner sees the construction. Khorezm has its own drier version. Cooks will tell you which is correct with the confidence of people discussing football.

The social side matters as much as the recipe. Large weddings and funerals are marked by nahor oshi, the morning palov, where hundreds of portions come out of a cauldron the size of a bathtub, cooked by a specialist oshpaz who does this and nothing else. In ordinary weeks palov is Thursday food in many households, and chaikhanas across the country cook one enormous kazan-load in the morning and sell it until it runs out, usually before two in the afternoon. Nobody reheats a cauldron of palov for a latecomer; you arrive on time or you eat lagman.

The home version below is scaled to a heavy casserole rather than a kazan and uses ordinary lamb shoulder plus a little extra fat in place of dumba, the fat-tailed sheep fat that gives restaurant palov its particular perfume. The technique is unchanged, and it is the technique that makes the dish.

Questions, answered.

Why is my plov sticky instead of having separate grains?

Almost always one of three things: the rice was not rinsed and soaked long enough, so surface starch glued the grains together; the rice was stirred after it went into the pot, which breaks grains and releases more starch; or there was too much liquid at the rice stage. The broth should sit only about 1.5 cm above the flat rice layer before the lid goes on.

What is zirvak and why does it matter?

Zirvak is the seasoned base of meat, onion, carrot, spices and broth that is built before any rice is added. It is where all the flavour and salt of the finished dish live, because the rice itself is never seasoned directly — it simply drinks the zirvak up. If the zirvak tastes flat or under-salted, the plov will too, and there is no fixing it later.

Do I need a kazan to make Uzbek plov?

No. A kazan is a thick round-bottomed cauldron that spreads heat up its curved walls, but a heavy cast-iron Dutch oven or a deep, wide casserole with a tight lid does the same job at home. What matters is thick walls, enough width for the rice to sit in a flat layer, and a lid that traps steam. A thin pan will scorch the base before the rice steams.

Can I make plov with chicken or beef instead of lamb?

Yes, and both are cooked in Uzbekistan. Beef chuck or shin behaves much like lamb but wants around 20 minutes longer in the zirvak to become tender. Chicken thighs work but need a shorter zirvak — about 15 minutes — or they shred away, and you will want extra oil since chicken renders far less fat than lamb.

Why are whole heads of garlic buried in the rice?

The unpeeled heads steam rather than fry, turning soft, sweet and mild instead of pungent, and they perfume the rice around them from the inside. At the table they are pulled out whole and squeezed onto portions or shared out clove by clove. Peeling or chopping the garlic instead gives a sharper, more ordinary garlic flavour and loses the effect.

Is plov the same as pilaf or pulao?

They belong to the same family, which stretches from Iran through Central Asia to South Asia, but the Uzbek method is specific: a fried meat-and-carrot zirvak built first, rice added in a flat unstirred layer on top, and heavy use of cumin, sweet carrot and lamb fat rather than saffron, garam masala or yogurt. Persian polow and Indian pulao are cooked and seasoned quite differently.

All recipes →