Beef Stroganoff.

Name: Beef Stroganoff (Beef Strips in Mustard Sour Cream)
Prep time: 15 min
Cook time: 20 min
Total time: 35 min
Yield: 4 servings
Cuisine: Russia
Ingredients: 600 g beef tenderloin or sirloin, in 1 cm strips across the grain; 1 tbsp plain flour; to taste salt and freshly ground black pepper; 40 g butter; 1 tbsp neutral oil, for searing; 2 onions, halved and finely sliced; 250 g mushrooms, thickly sliced; 200 ml beef stock; 2 tsp Dijon or Russian mustard; 250 g full-fat smetana or sour cream, at room temperature; 3 tbsp parsley, chopped; 2 tbsp dill, chopped

Beef Strips in Mustard Sour Cream

Бефстроганов · Befstroganov · say it: bef-STROH-gah-nof

Beef Stroganoff is beef cut into short strips, seared fast in a very hot pan, and finished in a sauce built from softened onion, mustard, a little stock and a lot of sour cream. Done properly it is not a stew and not a creamy pasta sauce: the meat stays pink inside, the sauce clings rather than pools, and the flavor leans tangy and sharp from the mustard rather than heavy. The whole thing takes about half an hour, most of which is slicing and softening onions. Russians serve it with fried potatoes or with buckwheat, not with wide egg noodles — that pairing was added later abroad, and it is good, but it is not where the dish came from.

Jump to the recipe

Read the story

Beef Strips in Mustard Sour Cream

Gate: Russia
Prep: 15 min
Cook: 20 min
Total time: 35 min
Serves: 4
Status: Easy
Nutrition / serving · estimated: Calories 520 kcal; Protein 38 g; Carbs 11 g; Fat 35 g; Fiber 2 g; Sodium 620 mg

Why this recipe works.

Sears the beef in batches in a screaming pan, so the strips brown instead of steaming into grey.
Tempers the sour cream before it goes into the pan, which is the step that stops the sauce from splitting.
Follows the original mustard-forward seasoning rather than burying the dish in cream and paprika.
Mushrooms are included as an option and labelled honestly as a later addition, not as the authentic core.

Tips from our kitchen.

Cut the beef across the grain into strips about 1 cm thick and 5 cm long. Thicker pieces need longer cooking and will be tough or overdone by the time the sauce is ready.
Dry the meat on paper towel before it hits the pan. Wet beef steams, and a steamed strip never browns no matter how hot the pan is.
Sear in two or three batches. Crowding the pan drops the temperature instantly and you get grey meat swimming in its own juices.
Take the pan off the heat before the sour cream goes in, and stir a ladle of hot pan liquid into the cream first — that is what keeps it smooth.
Return the beef to the sauce only in the last minute. It has already cooked; anything more turns tenderloin into shoe leather.
Use full-fat sour cream, at least 20% fat. Low-fat versions curdle almost on contact with heat.

Substitutions.

Beef tenderloin → Sirloin, rump steak or flat iron, sliced thin across the grain: Tenderloin is traditional and forgiving, but any quick-cooking steak works if you slice it thinly. Avoid stewing cuts entirely — they need hours, not minutes.
Smetana (sour cream) → Full-fat crème fraîche, or Greek yogurt loosened with cream: Crème fraîche is the most reliable substitute because it resists splitting. Plain yogurt will curdle unless it is stabilised with a teaspoon of flour first.
Russian mustard → Dijon mustard, or English mustard used at half the quantity: Russian table mustard is much hotter than Dijon. If you have it, use less; if you use English mustard, start with half and taste.

Variations.

With mushrooms: Fry 250 g of sliced mushrooms after the onions until their liquid has evaporated and they squeak against the pan, then continue. Not in the earliest recipes, but now the most common version worldwide.
The tomato version: Add a tablespoon of tomato paste with the onions and fry it until brick red. Some nineteenth-century Russian recipes include it, and it gives the sauce a rounder, slightly sweet body.
Estrogonofe brasileiro: The Brazilian descendant: chicken or beef in a sauce of cream, tomato paste and ketchup, served with rice and crisp potato sticks. A different dish now, and enormously popular in its own right.

Storage & reheating.

Stroganoff is best eaten straight from the pan, because the beef continues to cook in any stored sauce. It will keep 2 days refrigerated; reheat it very gently in a covered pan over the lowest heat, or in a bowl set over simmering water, and expect the meat to be firmer than it was. Do not freeze it — the sour cream separates on thawing and the sauce turns grainy. If you want a head start, slice the beef and make the onion base a day ahead, then sear and finish just before serving.

Serve with

Crisp fried potatoes, which is the Russian pairing, or buckwheat kasha. Wide egg noodles are the international default and work perfectly well.

The story behind Beef Stroganoff.

The dish is named after the Stroganovs, one of the wealthiest families in imperial Russia, and it belongs to the nineteenth-century world where French-trained chefs ran the kitchens of Russian noble houses. A recipe under the name appeared in Russian cookbooks in the 1870s, and the story usually attached to it — that a Stroganov count's chef devised it, in one version to suit an ageing employer who could no longer chew whole steaks — is repeated everywhere but not firmly documented. What is documented is the technique: small pieces of beef, a mustard-and-sour-cream sauce, and a very short cooking time. That combination is exactly the meeting point of the two kitchens, French sauce logic applied to smetana, the Russian sour cream that sits on almost every table.

The early printed versions are leaner than the dish most people know. They call for beef cut in cubes rather than strips, dusted with flour, fried, then simmered briefly in a mustard-flavored sour cream sauce, sometimes with a spoonful of tomato. Mushrooms — now treated as compulsory — are absent from the earliest recipes and crept in later, particularly outside Russia. So did paprika, brandy, and the whole business of serving it over noodles.

Stroganoff travelled unusually far and unusually fast. It became a standard of Russian restaurant menus, then of hotel cooking across Europe and China, then a mid-century staple in the United States, Brazil and Scandinavia, mutating in each place. Brazilian estrogonofe uses cream and tomato and often chicken; the American version leans on canned mushroom soup; the Nordic take goes heavy on paprika and pickles. All of them are real dishes with real followings, but the Russian original is sharper and simpler than any of them, and it is worth cooking once as it was written before deciding which version you prefer.

Questions, answered.

Why did my sour cream sauce split?

Sour cream curdles when it hits high heat or an acidic pan too fast. Take the pan off the burner, whisk a ladle of the hot cooking liquid into the sour cream in a separate bowl to warm it gradually, then stir that mixture back in over low heat and never let it boil. Using full-fat sour cream of at least 20% fat also makes splitting far less likely.

Does authentic beef Stroganoff contain mushrooms?

Not originally. The earliest published Russian recipes from the 1870s describe beef, mustard and sour cream with no mushrooms at all; they were added later and became standard mainly outside Russia. Mushrooms taste excellent in the dish, so use them if you like, but they are a modern layer rather than the authentic core.

Which cut of beef should I use?

A tender, quick-cooking cut: tenderloin is classic, and sirloin, rump or flat iron all work well when sliced thinly across the grain. Braising cuts such as chuck or shin are wrong for this dish because they need hours of slow cooking to soften, while Stroganoff cooks the meat for only a few minutes.

Is Stroganoff served over noodles in Russia?

Usually not. In Russia it is most often served with fried or mashed potatoes, or with buckwheat kasha. Serving it over wide egg noodles is an international convention that developed as the dish spread through Europe and North America, and it is a good pairing, just not the original one.

Can I make it ahead for a dinner party?

Partly. Slice the beef and cook the onion base up to a day in advance and refrigerate them separately. The searing and the sauce take under ten minutes, so finish the dish just before serving — reheated Stroganoff always has firmer meat and a slightly grainier sauce than freshly made.

All recipes →