English Scones with Clotted Cream and Jam.

Name: English Scones with Clotted Cream and Jam
Prep time: 15 min
Cook time: 13 min
Total time: 28 min
Yield: 8 servings
Cuisine: United Kingdom
Ingredients: 350 g plain flour, plus extra for dusting; 1 tbsp baking powder; ½ tsp fine salt; 85 g cold butter, cubed; 40 g caster sugar; 180 ml whole milk, cold; 1 egg, beaten, for glazing; 1 tsp vanilla extract; 100 g sultanas or raisins; 250 g clotted cream; 250 g strawberry or raspberry jam

An English scone is a plain, lightly sweetened bread cut thick, baked at high heat and eaten warm with clotted cream and jam. Done right it rises straight up rather than spreading, splits in half under gentle pressure from the thumbs without a knife, and has a crumb that is soft and slightly flaky rather than cakey. The dough takes about eight minutes to make and every mistake comes from doing too much to it — overworking, over-rolling, twisting the cutter. Scones are a lesson in restraint, and they are best eaten within an hour of leaving the oven.

Jump to the recipe

Read the story

English Scones with Clotted Cream and Jam

Gate: United KingdomSouth West England
Prep: 15 min
Cook: 13 min
Total time: 28 min
Serves: 8
Status: Easy
Nutrition / serving · estimated: Calories 430 kcal; Protein 7 g; Carbs 52 g; Fat 22 g; Fiber 2 g; Sugar 22 g

Why this recipe works.

Cold butter rubbed in coarsely, which gives flakes and lift rather than a uniform cakey crumb.
A wet, barely mixed dough — the single biggest reason home scones come out dense is adding too little liquid and too much kneading.
Cut thick and pressed straight down, so the scones climb instead of spreading sideways.
Twelve minutes in a hot oven, which sets the outside fast and traps the rise.

Tips from our kitchen.

Use butter straight from the fridge and stop rubbing while there are still visible flakes. Fully rubbed-in butter gives a scone with no layers.
Add the liquid all at once and bring the dough together with a knife, not your hands. It should feel wetter and stickier than you are comfortable with.
Pat the dough out to at least 3 cm thick. Rolled thin, a scone can only ever rise so far.
Push the cutter straight down and lift it straight up — twisting seals the cut edge and makes the scone rise lopsided.
Dip the cutter in flour between each scone so it releases cleanly instead of dragging the dough.
Brush the tops with egg or milk but keep it off the sides; glaze running down the cut edge glues it shut and stops the rise.

Substitutions.

Clotted cream → Very thick whipped double cream, or mascarpone loosened with cream: Nothing quite replaces clotted cream, which is scalded and has around 55 percent fat and a faint cooked-milk flavour. Whipped double cream is the closest widely available option; do not use squirty cream, which collapses on contact.
Whole milk → Buttermilk, with 1 tsp bicarbonate of soda replacing 1 tsp of the baking powder: Buttermilk gives a slightly tangier scone and a very tender crumb. It is the traditional Scottish and Irish approach.
Plain flour plus baking powder → Self-raising flour, omitting the baking powder: Standard in British kitchens and completely interchangeable. If your self-raising flour has been open a while, add half a teaspoon of baking powder as insurance — raising agents lose strength.

Variations.

Fruit scones: A large handful of sultanas or raisins folded in with the liquid. The most common British version and the standard in a tea room.
Cheese scones: Strong Cheddar and a teaspoon of mustard powder in the dough with the sugar reduced to a pinch, topped with more cheese before baking. Eaten with butter and soup rather than jam.
Griddle scones: The older Scottish method: the dough patted into a round, cut into wedges and cooked on a hot dry griddle for a few minutes a side rather than baked.

Storage & reheating.

Scones are at their best within two hours of baking and noticeably worse the next day. Keep them in a paper bag rather than an airtight box, which traps steam and turns the crust soft. They freeze extremely well: cool completely, bag, and freeze for 3 months, then refresh from frozen at 180°C for 8 minutes, which comes out closer to fresh than a day-old scone. Unbaked cut dough also freezes and can be baked from frozen with 4 extra minutes.

Serve with

Clotted cream, strawberry or raspberry jam, and a pot of strong tea. Assemble in whichever county order you defend.

The story behind English Scones with Clotted Cream and Jam.

The scone comes originally from Scotland, where it was a large round of dough cooked on a griddle and cut into wedges, and the name may derive from the Dutch schoonbrood or from the Stone of Scone — neither etymology is settled. The oven-baked, individually cut scone is a later English development, and it took off in the nineteenth century when bicarbonate of soda and then baking powder became household items, since scones depend entirely on chemical raising agents working fast in a hot oven.

What made the scone a national institution is cream tea, and here Devon and Cornwall have been arguing for well over a century. Both counties claim the tradition and both insist on a different order of assembly: Devon puts clotted cream on the split scone first and jam on top, treating the cream like butter; Cornwall spreads jam first and adds a spoonful of cream on top. The Cornish position has some structural logic — cream sitting on top does not get smeared by the jam spoon — but nobody chooses their side on logic. It is a genuine local loyalty and it is taken more seriously than it sounds.

The second argument is pronunciation, which splits along class and regional lines rather than county ones: the vowel that rhymes with "gone" and the vowel that rhymes with "cone" are both standard and both defended. Meanwhile afternoon tea itself — scones, sandwiches and cake between lunch and dinner — is a Victorian invention that became a hotel ritual, and it is now the setting in which most people outside the south-west encounter a scone at all. In Devon and Cornwall it is simply what you eat in the afternoon, cream tea being a meal rather than an event.

Questions, answered.

Why did my scones come out flat and heavy?

Almost always one of three things: the dough was rolled too thin, it was overworked, or the cutter was twisted. Pat the dough to at least 3 cm and handle it as little as possible — a rough, shaggy dough makes a better scone than a smooth one. Twisting the cutter pinches the cut edge closed and physically stops the layers from lifting.

Jam or cream first?

Devon puts clotted cream on first and jam on top; Cornwall puts jam on first and cream on top. Both are correct in their own county and the disagreement is genuine, long-running and enjoyed. Practically, jam first is slightly tidier because the cream does not get streaked by the jam spoon, but no one in Devon considers that an argument.

What is clotted cream and can I make it?

Clotted cream is cream heated slowly and held at a low temperature for hours until a thick crust forms on top, then cooled — a Devon and Cornwall speciality with about 55 percent butterfat and a faintly cooked, nutty flavour. You can make it at home by baking unpasteurised or pasteurised double cream at 80°C for 10–12 hours in a shallow dish, then chilling overnight. It will not work with ultra-pasteurised cream.

Should scones be sweet or savoury?

A plain English scone is only lightly sweetened — the sugar is there for browning and balance, not to make a cake — because the sweetness is supposed to come from the jam. Cheese scones drop the sugar almost entirely and take on mustard and Cheddar. American-style scones are a different, richer, much sweeter thing built with cream and butter.

How do I get a really tall, straight rise?

Hot oven, thick dough, sharp cutter and a light hand. Bake at 220°C so the outside sets before the scone can spread, cut them at least 3 cm thick, and place them close together on the tray so they support each other as they climb. Keeping the egg wash off the cut sides matters more than most recipes admit.

All recipes →